Ysabel Muñoz
In recent years, small islands have faced the increasing dangers of worsening natural phenomena and rising sea levels due to climate change. Several reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change have recorded this (Mycoo et al. 2068) and warned about the consequences of unsustainable practices leading to ecological crises primarily affecting those who contribute least to it. Such documentation is crucial for policy-making and preparatory work. However, besides material threats, small islands also face a discursive challenge in politics and communication with the overuse of the âdisappearing islandsâ trope, announcing that small islands will sink and disappear due to climate change. As museologist Fiona Cameron writes, ââdisappearing islandsâ are operationalized as proof of climate catastrophe; as a means of concretizing climate scienceâs statistical abstractions and as a signifier of the urgency and uneven impacts of global climate changeâ (873). Similarly, environmental humanities scholar Elizabeth DeLoughrey denounces the âclimate determinismâ (âThe sea is risingâ 191) that often haunts the representation of islands, as if they only âenter[ed] the future [âŠ] via climate changeâ (188). Such overly reproduced images, they argue, risk ignoring local perspectives and desires, taking islands simply as tokens to better describe the climate crisis. Hence, a more critical approach to the futurity of small islands is necessary and relevant. Although studies of this trope have been mostly connected to islands in the Pacific regions, such imaginaries also haunt the material spaces of Caribbean islands.1 Responding to this, digital humanities scholar Schuyler Esprit affirms that âthe decolonial project of home is to assert that the Caribbean is in the future, that we resist and persistâ (emphasis added). In these spaces, the possible physical disappearance of islands in the future also echoes discriminatory discourses that have actively denied the future of certain bodies deemed different based on race, sexuality, or gender. Literary practices, performing and nurturing speculation and imagining otherwise, are important platforms where authors who experience these overlapping threats can articulate their concerns for the future. Notably, examples from queer and trans Caribbean speculative fiction disrupt the simplified and linear visions the âdisappearing islandsâ trope proposes. They address how both islands and marginalized bodies face growing social and climate change challenges but still imagine these bodies and places having a stake in the future. By revisiting the histories and concerns of these spaces and their inhabitants, they project the Caribbean into a future, to paraphrase Esprit, of resistance and persistence. In this study, I delve into how contemporary Anglophone Caribbean speculative fiction grapples with these questions, especially in two short stories: Jamaican-Canadian Nalo Hopkinsonâs âRepatriationâ (2020) and Barbadian Ada Maricia Pattersonâs âBroken from the Colonyâ (2022). These texts envision a future where Caribbean islands are not disappearing but transforming and surviving, together with the flourishing of queer and trans Caribbean subjects. Hopkinson presents the return of a same-sex couple to Jamaica to take part in the reconstruction of the island with local technologies. Patterson meanwhile brings a sunken island that reemerges, allowing new relationalities where transgender subjects can feel safe. In both accounts, non-heteronormative characters play key roles in island survival and illustrate how ecological balance and gender justice are inextricably connected to achieving its mutual realization. They contest the âdisappearing islandsâ trope by daring to imagine islands in the future as transitioning and changing rather than simply ceasing to exist. Moreover, they foreground agency and responsibility as the collective effort needed to create social ecologies of justice where land and lives can thrive. Choosing short stories for the analysis is also a critique of gendered dimensions of Caribbean literature that traditionally have deemed the canon of male novel writers as âthe pinnacle of formal achievementâ (Brown and Rosenberg 22), disregarding short stories as âminor literature.â I defend that with its capacity for language subversion and deterritorialization (Awadalla and March-Russell 5), short stories also show the possibility of imagining plurally and yet collectively, as they often appear in compilations and decentralized open-access online platforms. With this in mind, attending to the diversity of practitioners of this genre in the Caribbean is also essential. Hence, this study purposefully brings Hopkinsonâa multi-awarded and trailblazing figure in science fiction, with an extensive list of novels, short stories, and accoladesâand her work next to the first incursion in speculative fiction of the young artist Patterson, signaling different trajectories and experiences but similar interests. Their stories coincide in the centrality of queer and trans folks in Caribbean ecologies through various examples of what can fall under the rubric of climate fiction, or âcli-fi.â However, as this term coined by Dan Bloom (Baysal viii) is increasingly popular in ecocritical studies, I emphasize that climate is an already widely present category in the Caribbeanâs vast literary tradition, especially with the figure of the hurricane (Deckard) as a ubiquitous leitmotif. While acknowledging the challenges of climate changeâs worsening of natural phenomena, such as hurricanes, it is paramount to recognize a long Caribbean tradition of periodically dealing with disaster and restoration. These experiences reaffirm that disaster does not define Caribbean existence and propose novel perspectives for understanding and grappling with catastrophe. Considering these contexts and genealogies, multiple rich theoretical apparatuses already active in the Caribbean enable researchers to analyze future-oriented narratives. For example, Caribbean temporalities can dispel the linear and singular thinking behind the âdisappearing islandsâ and its alienation from other notions of time.2 As Cameron reflects, âconstructed as both a climate front line and a microcosm of a planet in crisis, a perception has been created that low-lying islands will disappear before climate impacts manifest elsewhereâ (883) (emphasis in original). By contrast, past, present, and future collapse in Caribbean narratives and bring a more capacious understanding of temporality outside conventional linearity. This nonlinearity is embodied in the work of many Caribbean writers. Jamaica Kincaid, for example, considers how âTo the people of a small place, [âŠ] an event that occurred one hundred years ago might be as vivid to them as it were happening now. No action in the present is an action planned without a view of its effects on the futureâ (54). Accordingly, Odile Ferly, Tegan Zimmerman, and Joshua Deckman have recently coined the term chronotropics, reframing the Bakhtinian chronotope through narratives that âactively challenge the anthropocentric and androcentric logic propelled by European capitalism according to which space is delimited, privatized, tamed, and subject to extraction and time is measured, linear, singular, arbitrarily standardized, and teleologicalâ (2). To focus on the plural ways Caribbean people experience time and place does not respond solely to an interest of moving away from âeurochronologies,â which Eric Hayot defines as âa progressive history of aesthetic innovation in which the contributions of the non-West remain supplemental, or constitute thematic appendixes to formâ (6). Instead, it emphasizes the intrinsic value of the narratives emerging from the vibrant Caribbean chronotropics. This concept is part of a homonymous edited volume that addresses the persistent preoccupation with time and place in Caribbean womenâs writings, thus providing a framework for my analysis. The concept includes time, temporalities, and gender, articulating âa new Caribbean, where bodies and imaginations come together to propose other modes of being in the world, ways that dissolve and break through the sediment of colonial-heteronormative patriarchyâ (7). I argue that the chronotropics can also enable imaginative pathways toward island survival and gender justice, attending to how queer and transgender practices are deeply entangled with processes of futurity. Attesting to this, for example, Cuban-American cultural theorist JosĂ© Esteban Muñoz reflects that queer lives already drastically reject the constraints of a present notably marked by pervasive homophobia and dare to imagine otherwise (169). Likewise, Puerto Rican anthropologist Yarimar Bonilla concludes in her analysis of transgender performers in post-hurricane Puerto Rico that many the future is thus a futureâ Although deeply entangled in their I queer studies scholar by I to that which of the and to the challenge of gender on embodied experiences and Moreover, I the with in queer and trans ecologies to the contributions from the Caribbean in such I and in with the the authors in and literary In their writings, I the of both queer and trans as that actively the future of the âdisappearing as by the two short and are that have traditionally in to by novel to gender and As aesthetic Hopkinson and Patterson and to contribute to the that the âdisappearing islandsâ trope In they about islands as âa of in not disappearing but rather and for the survival of islands and They the of that the of islands, and also that be a disappearance islands other in the Caribbean This does not climate changeâs and material threats to islandsâ and I not that these stories in which islands are Instead, I argue that in these Caribbean islands have multiple of being in the future via and While the faced by small island and queer and trans they challenge and of the present with and more capacious of the Caribbean chronotropics. Such of the Caribbean chronotropics appear in of Hopkinsonâs vast literary as by on her For how Hopkinson a Caribbean in which haunt the present Similarly, how Hopkinsonâs work temporalities by that the for Caribbean islands is the in of and of change a future that to Caribbean islands to the as in the of its logic in of and is not a that in the of the are present in both the environmental history and social and of Caribbean islands as in the Caribbean be as a of the Hence, speculative fiction writers the of such as a imaginative to the of and This also behind the short in which Hopkinson and her characters return to their Jamaica to about and in its which are not by but its âRepatriationâ first in the edited volume in with other examples of by the I âRepatriationâ in the of the speculative fiction from the Caribbean edited by science fiction writers and The stories for this volume contribute to what âa of science and Hopkinsonâs to this together with ecological concerns and local The is in first from the of view of one of the who a planned by As the the the of the the couple will return to Jamaica to the of the This of through a that are to the of the island the I the analysis by on of as a of the The with a critique of a in different of the world, has its in the Caribbean the and and with feel on a In a Hopkinson reflects on this to of of the and of and for dealing with the are to the As an island I about that a and the marked a history of for from of the âthe the and the and the islandsâ The this history of and not as a of the but in with environmental such as the of local with and its to global on the in these critical of its âRepatriationâ and the ecological crises taking place in the which to how which the levels to many of These the island by its and to to as the ways to a of its The to into the of ecological by the into of for the on the and on and than The if the that on it are their and or what the is the of to the of a singular future in which Caribbean islands the they The Hopkinson as a for the into the This local and queer folks Hopkinson and her two to contribute to the Hopkinson brings the perspectives of two for the of climate and still the they in this âthe that with as a a in my race, and in these on as are not and have been for the bodies deemed than in a of and This presents challenges for bodies under social and environmental as their are through digital and with The in on the to the Such to a more history of practices as and The has of the history of bodies and the the lives in the due to the To that one the in toward the the of the Caribbean and and the of due to climate To how folks in the Caribbean are to climate it is paramount to the of the in These of in to to the However, with they the home of but of material These new and to to but also folks to the consequences of climate change As people will to be away from these due to and climate is one of the concerns in The their as climate to to rising levels and global were and and In to this, not in the other environmental queer folks often an of discriminatory have and from et al. Hence, it is to the that climate on queer of these the two in this are not or but on their to in the needed change in their the of the Caribbean as only moving toward the global narratives have a long in Caribbean and in this queer subjects in to the and also the of island disappearance rather than an land the emphasizes Jamaica as a place of and and in without being As and in to the of Caribbean are by the from an and by the from land Hence, the Caribbean and its as a home that has not been with more of ecological The rich for the future of queer and Caribbean in âRepatriationâ a new futurity that and of to a place for new and more Such a approach to an by also queer By this, I not only that queer characters are crucial in these processes but also that the to imagine otherwise, not to the and also play roles in of as the the couple that processes being of the of to the with and by of them often to in the people that are more and to local and their for the future. This is for a home that does not with and as the this futurity only through and The that and and the the of new together with the this to the also in the with the âthe the under and many As Caribbean of them are in the space as one of agency and the challenges of but other relationalities that away from and The new island survival in with queer folks and also a on a The of sunken for and the future of the as a to the and of with and not the In these the of islands and not as I have also in queer ecologies on futurity. the of queer time has been as and not in the future this presents imaginative a to the survival of island spaces and the flourishing of queer Hence, both âRepatriationâ and âBroken from the as I challenge the of as the only to imagine futurity. Instead, they survival and the of the and futurity queer and trans characters with practices of ecological and these imaginative artist and Patterson reflects on disaster through transgender perspectives in the short âBroken from the where the of islands and the survival of trans The short is her to the first of the Climate for by in The climate fiction stories that imagine years into the future, in the of Pattersonâs it and and its the has the of with the recent The of and to it. âBroken from the Colonyâ presents a Caribbean future in which enable transgender to and to with their survival natural the of an transgender the the before and of a hurricane the category that the Caribbean in Although the and in the has a more islands and many various the the through a the and the as a space for the and sea are spaces of and where the that are but of Patterson in the sea and with new of being in a world, yet the the to return to land the island The in the land of a place for âBroken from the by providing a space of and to In this transgender perspectives a in which the and in to envision change toward flourishing islands and This Caribbean trans experiences on their island in studies such as and However, rather than them only as I propose that Pattersonâs work to actively the of the âdisappearing by a island from a space of to one of and thus thinking with trans and their in and are and in Pattersonâs to a decolonial of climate her I defend the centrality of trans practices as that and in this more than an environmental the of and that the island the before the Although the with her in the sea for the the land where the subject as the and has place for âBroken from the Several the to as the land in such as to and the in the The that the with land that the space her trans and her with to the past, yet of what it for her the and feel in her that and her people her for Hence, the as a of signaling the by the this, her only island No of which it the For this a new in the as a for the as in the of The and the sea the The space in the of the âBroken from the In with the Barbadian who have in the in the a with the its capacity to to other possible and it as a of the sea has for the sea their growing with and as they of one of the to their been âBroken from the This the of for the survival and of trans bodies that have recently more being to and et al. Moreover, in with trans the echoes the challenges to notions of the of bodies bodies are to of by the that island survival on the in Hopkinsonâs The the to with reflects on how these from of her changing their from and in other for bodies we in to what before âBroken from the This brings concept that trans studies to the trans with environmental that of and with the natural from a In this of are where the her to the sea also as a with in âBroken from the this challenges the and with these of the the of the as a of to the and of mutual the to experience and The to be a but not this and to and an âBroken from the of climate changeâ the of for as the a subject that and the of gendered and narratives. In this Patterson the of the to the a trans that the of and the of more in this to and her The as trans scholar challenges notions of as the and the enable a and the of new from a to the of the to change practices that the future to the of global and it can the lives of trans people of Moreover, in the of the means that and such can also be how they have been as an for the of many bodies also in this of Caribbean as the of the land that place on these islands only possible with the extraction of of of Patterson that a of is to new of of on this new land to be one of and âBroken from the The of these is to understanding the her emphasizes the of perspectives on islands that are not disappearing but Patterson that a critical of what islands are In âBroken from the the land emphasizes the of new and that from the people what who or what on or This with a tradition of understanding the of in the Caribbean, as the hurricane is as both a disaster and a of change to As Patterson and hurricane With the new it can create a in the of with place for is a for this not a but a reconstruction of ecological and and of the does not toward the from the that to dissolve her Instead, new for especially with the only of the They are a who the the the time her and they new with other who the The island a space of not only as an but as work and for the of the future. I this in the of decolonial that place land the as to the of islands and trans bodies in The that this time can be and in this new land before the In the Patterson in actively islands toward and with and and In of for the future of the and its small islands, Pattersonâs to the preoccupation with islandsâ disappearance to the in those spaces as a for futurity. in this for changing what to be a of and critical and a for the survival and flourishing of and The two of contemporary Anglophone Caribbean speculative fiction in this challenge the of the âdisappearing islandsâ by islands as spaces in processes of and change. Hopkinsonâs âRepatriationâ and Pattersonâs âBroken from the Colonyâ narratives of and that break Caribbean as of and extraction and Caribbean Muñoz To they articulate narratives of gender and and critical to with climate and social through narratives of in the now. they describe of and the âdisappearing islandsâ trope by ecological with a more capacious the of based on gender or Their the of environmental collapse in with a critique of gender and Considering and the of narratives is paramount for understanding and a and future. of the with politics of and the or the roles in these in to and such as and Moreover, they as an for islands and The is also a that the capacity of to other possible a that and taking of Caribbean by its These narratives imaginative practices that for who will in them by revisiting of the with a as they present is not ecological but also the and of and transgender subjects. a future address and such the processes of bodies and from This is possible by the of and on the islands, toward that respond to and from These texts propose and for their mutual They foreground queer and trans with their ecologies that growing from and of providing more than In both the sea an that can or take lives but also an for into Caribbean and such as the islands also these in the Hopkinsonâs that a can its if land is an By contrast, Patterson presents an island being to In both land is a as and histories on it. than simply into of Caribbean, or these stories are examples of in queer and trans ecological new in the face of discursive and material The islands present of to of and enable their through and Such are important to vibrant contemporary speculative work and recognize practices as other for to a rich tradition of speculative the authors that such a genre in the of and a for in understanding how such as gender and ecologies are connected in the of these to climate is key to futurity not solely based on and but also on imaginative and cultural these practices are more through a growing of decentralized digital platforms that and the of In of environmental and social crisis, the collective imaginaries of futurity to the perspectives queer and trans narratives and Caribbean speculative fiction places on the of thinking about climate change through gender and queer and trans narratives to the Caribbean in the future. my analysis has the contributions of such I emphasize that these not and I not that queer or trans authors are more to or in ecological I to that queer and trans stories often respond to and denied to them through as in the of these two short stories, they can articulate new relationalities that as for the of important is that they land from discursive and physical this action the and to the Caribbean which to and By of gender and âRepatriationâ and âBroken from the Colonyâ imagine where Caribbean spaces and subjects and different ways of in with their ecological