Implied ETF Carry Rates and the Limits of Arbitrage in Segmented Bitcoin Markets

Abstract

This paper estimates the carry embedded in listed IBIT options and compares it with the carry embedded in matched CME bitcoin futures. Put-call parity recovers an implied forward on the ETF; BlackRock's daily holdings file maps each ETF share into bitcoin units; and CME futures prices and BRRNY, a U.S. close bitcoin reference rate, provide the corresponding futures-market carry. The difference in carry implied by these two products is consistent with frictions that limit cross-margining between spot bitcoin or ETF exposure and CME futures. In the selected-strike IBIT sample of 386 date-bucket observations, the mean wedge is 2.58 percent and the median wedge is 2.52 percent, both measured in annual percentage points. The result is consistent with segmented collateral and margin systems limiting arbitrage between regulated bitcoin-exposure venues.