Sustainability Uncertainty and Green Asset Volatility: Evidence from Decentralized Finance and Environmental, Social, and Governance Funds

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of sustainability-related uncertainty (SRU)—captured via the Sustainability-related Uncertainty Index in equal-weighted (ESGUI_EQ) and GDP-weighted (ESGUI_GDP) forms—on the volatility of green financial assets, focusing on decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols and Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)-focused Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs). Employing a fuzzy logic framework, complemented by 3D surface visualization, Rule Viewer analysis, diagnostic validation, and Granger causality tests, the study uncovers non-linear, asymmetric, and time-varying responses of these assets to sustainability ambiguity. Empirical results reveal a structural divergence: DeFi protocols amplify volatility due to fragmented governance, speculative investor behavior, and sensitivity to policy-driven signals, often exhibiting bidirectional predictive feedback with SRU, whereas ESG ETFs maintain stability through diversification, regulatory oversight, and rigorous ESG screening, primarily absorbing sustainability shocks. These findings extend sustainable finance theory by integrating governance, technology, and policy dimensions, and illustrate the value of fuzzy logic combined with Granger causality in modeling complex, ambiguous markets. From a practical standpoint, the study provides actionable guidance for investors, fund managers, and policymakers, emphasizing the importance of technology-informed governance, standardized ESG disclosures, regulatory sandboxes, and continuous monitoring of SRU.